A lawsuit regarding New York state’s algorithmic rent-setting ban is testing how far the government can go in restricting such tools without also overly impeding commercial speech, and may provide more clarity about what is within legal bounds, legal experts say.
Although it’s difficult to estimate how influential the ultimate decision in RealPage Inc. v. James will be, the preliminary ruling indicates “the case could provide meaningful guidance on how far state and local governments can go in regulating or restricting these technologies without running afoul of the First Amendment,” Corinne Migliazza, associate at real estate law firm Otten Johnson, told Multifamily Dive in emailed comments.
In 2024, the Department of Justice and several states sued Realpage and several major landlords that used its pricing product, alleging in United States et al. v. RealPage Inc. et al. that the use of algorithmic software to coordinate rents violated antitrust law. As settlements from that case started rolling out, New York became the first state, in 2025, to impose an outright ban on residential rent-pricing algorithms with its antitrust law amendment S.7882.
Before New York’s ban was set to take effect last year, Realpage went on the offensive. It sued the state in November 2025 on free speech grounds rather than making antitrust arguments. Then it asked the court to halt the ban while its case was being heard.
The federal judge agreed to grant a preliminary injunction at the end of September and also denied the state’s January request to dismiss the lawsuit. Judge Valerie Caproni said that some language of the ban likely restricts protected speech more broadly than necessary because it is “undiscerning in targeting software without regard to its use of public versus non-public data.”
Although the judge indicated the decision would be a close call, her ruling hints that the court is skeptical of New York’s restrictions, “at least enough to allow more evidence and fact to be developed and presented,” according to Migliazza.
“There are also suggestions that the Court may be more receptive to narrowly tailored restrictions, like the initial RealPage settlements, which restricted the algorithms to publicly available information, rather than prohibiting their use outright,” Migliazza said.
It remains to be seen whether the court will address particular uses of algorithmic rent-pricing tools in depth. It may decide to only rule on the constitutionality of New York’s restrictions and put the ball in the legislature’s court to find a better solution, according to Migliazza.
“Certainly, a First Amendment victory by RealPage would force the legislature back to the drawing board to contour the law towards constitutionality – meaning they would have to make the restrictions less severe,” Migliazza said.
New York case impact
Algorithmic rent-pricing restrictions are proliferating: New Jersey’s FAIR Act is set to take effect on July 1, 2027, although it is structured differently from New York’s law. Jersey City, New Jersey; Providence, Rhode Island; Philadelphia; Minneapolis; San Francisco; Seattle; Rockville, Maryland, have also passed similar measures.
That growing patchwork of algorithmic pricing laws is making compliance more complicated for the rental housing industry, Peter Carstensen, antitrust expert and professor of law emeritus at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, told Multifamily Dive. “What's a developer to do, especially if those regulations are in some way contrary to each other?” Carstensen said.
It’s important for rental housing firms to follow these information exchange lawsuits and antitrust litigation more broadly, and to ask, “What are the red lights or the yellow lights that we need to watch out for? How do we make sure that people down in marketing are not creating problems for us?” according to Carstensen.
Indeed, landlords are not necessarily in the clear to use algorithmic pricing tools, legal experts at law firm Lowenstein Sandler wrote. They urged caution in New York, and said to prepare for changes in New Jersey and varied algorithmic pricing laws more generally.
“Tools that pool competitors’ nonpublic data, discourage price reductions, standardize lease terms, or otherwise limit independent decision-making should be closely reviewed,” according to Lowenstein Sandler.
Consultation on the front end to ensure compliance with the relevant jurisdiction’s regulations could save a lot of time, energy and money later on, according to Migliazza, particularly as such regulations continue to evolve. “There is no doubt that as the technological landscape surrounding artificial intelligence changes, the legal one will too,” she said.
Recent case developments
For now, the New York case continues to unfold.
A few weeks following the court’s decision to halt the state’s ban, New York Attorney General Letitia James asked the judge to reconsider and vacate the injunction, per an Oct. 13 filing in the U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York. The state is arguing that Realpage lacks standing to represent third parties who are not named plaintiffs and that S.7882 represents constitutional regulation of commercial speech.
Realpage responded by asking the court to stand by its prior ruling, saying in an Oct. 27 filing, “The State simply disagrees with the Court’s conclusion, which is not a proper basis for reconsideration.”
Despite the parties’ differing positions, a settlement or ruling without a full jury trial is possible, according to an Oct. 22 joint filing.
“Both Parties contemplate filing a motion for summary judgment at the conclusion of expert
Discovery,” per the filing. “The Parties have discussed settlement and will continue to discuss whether a mutually agreeable resolution is possible.”
Click here to sign up to receive multifamily and apartment news like this article in your inbox every weekday.