A mass action lawsuit filed by military families against Balfour Beatty over “appalling” housing conditions in Florida at Naval Air Station Key West has moved from state to federal court, recent records show. One of the defendants, Balfour Beatty Communities, just finished its period of independent compliance monitoring, which the U.S. Department of Justice imposed after the company pled guilty to fraud in 2021 in a separate military housing case.
For decades, London-based building giant Balfour Beatty PLC and entities it controls — defendants Balfour Beatty Communities, Southeast Housing, Balfour Beatty Military Housing Management, BBC Military Housing-Navy Southeast and Balfour Beatty Investments — “have profited from a multi-billion-dollar corporate military housing monopoly that abuses, sickens, and traumatizes American military families,” the amended master complaint for In Re: Key West Nas Litigation, filed May 27 in the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida, alleges.
“Pleas by servicemember families to repair and remediate waterdamaged, mold-ridden, and pest-infested homes have been met with inadequate maintenance practices and corporate indifference or ineptitude,” the complaint claims. Now, plaintiffs seek damages “for injuries sustained as a result of Defendants’ intentional, negligent, and grossly negligent acts and omission” relating to their management of military housing at NAS Key West.
Balfour Beatty leases and manages more than 43,000 homes for the Army, Navy and Air Force, including 700 housing units at NAS Key West, the Military Times reported. The company denies the allegations and said the well-being of residents remains its highest priority.
“We disagree with the allegations outlined in the complaint and intend to defend ourselves vigorously,” a spokesperson for Balfour Beatty Communities said in emailed comments to Multifamily Dive.
In the original lawsuit, Jackie and Anthonie Talarico, et al., v. Balfour Beatty Communities LLC, et al., filed in the Circuit Court for Monroe County, Florida, in March 2025, 56 families reported ceilings collapsing from water damage, mold, insect infestations, structural defects, HVAC and plumbing issues, electrical problems, as well as lead paint and asbestos. Just Well Law filed an amended suit on Sept. 9, 2025, that increased the number of plaintiffs from 192 to 272, Keys Weekly reported.
In such a mass action lawsuit, individual cases are coordinated for efficiency, typically after plaintiffs sustained injuries at the hands of the same defendants caused by an identical harmful act, according to Morris Bart law. However, every plaintiff remains an individual party seeking personalized compensation.
Previous military housing fraud
Balfour Beatty Communities completed its period of independent compliance monitorship on June 6, imposed after the company pleaded guilty in December 2021 to defrauding the U.S. military by falsifying housing repair records from 2013 to 2019 to receive higher performance awards. Balfour Beatty agreed to pay $65 million in fines and restitution and to engage an independent compliance monitor, per a Justice Department release.
The following year, a U.S. Senate report called for more robust oversight of Balfour Beatty, citing ongoing management failures and noting that some of Balfour Beatty’s staff “did not appear to prioritize health and safety concerns or take steps to investigate or correct inaccurate work order data despite Balfour’s having been under active DOJ investigation for similar types of previous behavior.”
To that end, Balfour Beatty Communities said in its June 8 release that it has implemented a broad improvement program, which included strengthening leadership and oversight structure; enhancing reporting and accountability mechanisms; and implementing more robust governance, compliance and operational processes.
“The conclusion of the monitorship marks an important milestone and Communities will continue to embed these improvements as part of its long-term operating model, while maintaining a strong focus on transparency, consistent delivery, operational performance, and the resident experience,” Balfour Beatty Communities said in the release.
“Communities remains committed to working closely with the US military service branches to provide safe, reliable, and well-maintained housing for service members and their families while ensuring a strong compliance environment and operational framework.”
Case history
Congress enacted the Military Housing Privatization Initiative in 1996 to improve the state of military housing. Under the MHPI, a private contractor is granted a long-term real property lease of military base grounds and serves as the landlord, according to the complaint. The contractor is responsible for building and renovating homes and then leasing, operating, managing and maintaining this housing.
The contractor typically collects the full amount of its residents’ Basic Allowance for Housing, regardless of the home’s size or condition, as well as performance incentive fees, which are payable upon approval by the relevant military department. To collect those fees, MHPI contractors must submit proof that they have satisfied performance objectives, such as maintenance and resident satisfaction. In 2021, Balfour Beatty admitted to falsifying such proof documents.
Although the MHPI has led to some improvements, it has also been plagued by reports of contractors, including Balfour Beatty, “prioritizing profits over their obligation to provide safe and habitable housing to service members and their families,” according to the complaint.
Sarah Kline, founder and director of community outreach at Armed Forces Housing Advocates, an organization that aims to help military families living in substandard conditions, previously told Multifamily Dive that she saw issues beyond Balfour Beatty Communities.
“We have searched and we have not been able to find a Military Housing Privatization Initiative community that military families aren’t living in sub-par housing,” Kline said. “There may be one or two homes within most communities, but there are problems within all of those projects.”
The Florida plaintiffs filed their lawsuit to hold Balfour Beatty accountable for its negligence and “utter failure to provide the safe and habitable housing that military families deserve, and that Balfour was contractually obligated to provide,” per the complaint. “Only with accountability will these conditions change.”
Click here to sign up to receive multifamily and apartment news like this article in your inbox every weekday.
